Benford's Law  this is great
 JimLombard
 Casual User
 Posts: 15
 Joined: Tue May 27, 2014 2:40 am
Benford's Law  this is great
I just happened to be reading an old article about it and it peaked my interest. I guess not too many people (even statisticians) were too familiar with it up until 1015 years ago, but it is getting very popular as it is being used to detect fraud in corporations, tax documents, etc. by simply looking at the numbers involved.
I know this is a bit out of topic for these forums, but I think it's such an interesting topic, that I wanted to tell people about it. See attached documents below.
I know this is a bit out of topic for these forums, but I think it's such an interesting topic, that I wanted to tell people about it. See attached documents below.
 Attachments

 RFewster_Benford.pdf
 (756.76 KiB) Downloaded 217 times

 BenfordsLaw03.PDF
 (698.7 KiB) Downloaded 232 times
Luck is not a factor. Hope is not a strategy. Fear is not an option  James Cameron
Re: Benford's Law  this is great
This is indeed off topic, as far as the forum goes, but is a very interesting topic to me. I also only recently became aware of Benford's Law and am fascinated with it!
I have seen many mentions of it having been used in real legal cases, but have not been able to find and case law for it. Do you happen to know of any such cases? I'd love to read up on them.
I have seen many mentions of it having been used in real legal cases, but have not been able to find and case law for it. Do you happen to know of any such cases? I'd love to read up on them.
Re: Benford's Law  this is great
Not sure how well this theory applies to the real world. I run a simulation by creating 1.2 million random numbers in the range 199999 in excel and then analyzed the first digit (19) frequency. I ended up with about 11% for each digit, totally different than what Benford's law suggested.
Am I doing something wrong?
Am I doing something wrong?
I have not failed. I’ve just found 10,000 ways that won’t work  Thomas A. Edison
Re: Benford's Law  this is great
Oscarg, my findings are similar to yours. I am sure there is a logical explanation, I just don't know what it is.
If anyone here can shed some light, it would be great!
If anyone here can shed some light, it would be great!
Vegetarian: Indian word for lousy hunter
Re: Benford's Law  this is great
Wait, isn't that exactly what his premise is? That "made up" numbers are not random, in terms of the first digit?
I may have totally misread this, but I think what you found proves his point.
I may have totally misread this, but I think what you found proves his point.
Re: Benford's Law  this is great
Hmm, you may be right. Have you looked at anything yourself that sort of proves his theory?
Vegetarian: Indian word for lousy hunter
Re: Benford's Law  this is great
Yes, I had looked at it a while ago and I had analyzed the populations of 227 countries in 1950. It was a quick and dirty thing, but here is what the results looked like: Pretty good, IMO. The first digit frequencies seem to agree with Benford's law.
Re: Benford's Law  this is great
Well, I don't know how helpful it is, but I found another short paper on this site's "techs" section that deals with this subject.
http://triusinc.com/techs/QuickBenford_Karahalios.pdf
It's fairly simple and doesn't go deep into math, but it may provide some additional insight.
http://triusinc.com/techs/QuickBenford_Karahalios.pdf
It's fairly simple and doesn't go deep into math, but it may provide some additional insight.
Re: Benford's Law  this is great
BLarson wrote: ↑Thu Nov 16, 2017 4:42 amWell, I don't know how helpful it is, but I found another short paper on this site's "techs" section that deals with this subject.
http://triusinc.com/techs/QuickBenford_Karahalios.pdf
It's fairly simple and doesn't go deep into math, but it may provide some additional insight.
Wow, actually, the plot from the paper you references (see below) displays similar behavior to what I had looked at. Does that constitute Independent verification?
Re: Benford's Law  this is great
I found this very interesting reallife case study of Benford's Law.
https://acfeinsights.squarespace.com/ac ... casestudy
https://acfeinsights.squarespace.com/ac ... casestudy
Vegetarian: Indian word for lousy hunter